Sign In | Create an Account | Welcome, . My Account | Logout | Subscribe | Submit News | Customer Service | Contact Us | Routes Available | All Access E-Edition | Home RSS

Designer babies?

October 9, 2013 - Andrea Johnson
While I have enjoyed learning more about my family tree since I had my DNA tested through 23andme a few weeks ago, I also find myself wondering about potential ethical problems with this kind of testing.

I see that the company I used, 23andme, has received a patent that would let parents at fertility clinics use the software to combine their genomes and determine which traits their child is most likely to inherit. It might work best with a couple who are looking for an egg donor or a sperm donor or both. Most ethically, it could be used to reduce the chance of a child inheriting a terrible disease; less ethically, it could be used to help parents pick their child's eye color and certain personality traits or even IQ.

While 23andme claims it has no plans to develop a "designer baby" program, I'm sure gene mapping will make it very possible in the future, by them or by some other genetics testing company. This 21st century eugenics is already being practiced by people who pick a certain sperm or egg donor based on looks and intelligence. Gene mapping will only make it easier for them to do it.

There are also some unintended consequences of this type of testing. Among the nearly 1,000 distant cousins 23andme matched me with as "DNA relatives" were two adoptees. Another woman, according to a forum post, found out that the father she grew up with isn't really her biological father when she persuaded him to send in a DNA sample to the company. When she confronted her mother, the woman admitted that her biological father is someone else and said, "I didn't think I'd ever be caught." In her forum posts, the woman sounds devastated.

I have also read a handful of blogs by enthusiastic users who decided to test their children's DNA through 23andme. One man had adopted a son from Vietnam and wanted to know more about his heritage; another tested her two sons. While this may provide valuable health information to the parents, it may also tell them some things they don't want to know and can do nothing about. Will it benefit a child to know that he carries a gene for Huntington's disease or early onset Alzheimer's and will have a vastly shortened life span? Is that a decision his parents have a right to make for him?

Privacy is also a concern and one I weighed carefully before I decided to participate. For me, it was worth any potential loss of privacy to try to find out more about my Finnish ancestry and the mystery of where my great-grandfather was from. I was also quite certain that I wasn't going to find any truly unpleasant information in either my health or ancestry results. Luckily, I was right, though there are a few things in the report I got back (and my subsequent in-depth exploration of the family tree) that will likely surprise some of my relatives. Not all of them may feel about the information the way that I do, either, so some of that information will remain in the family for now.

What do you make of 23andme? Would you have your own DNA tested? Would you have your children tested?


Article Comments



Oct-10-13 1:38 PM

== Continued == I'd add that I don't think shared DNA necessarily adds up to a family relationship or that it takes anything away from love for adoptive family members. My grandfather had an adoptive mother (a biological aunt) and an adoptive father (her husband) whom he loved very much and who were definitely his parents just as much as the ones who gave him life. I carry his surname and was indirectly named after that adoptive great-grandfather. I am looking for information on the biological great-grandfather as much out of curiosity as anything else.


Oct-10-13 1:34 PM

Probably a scary thing for anyone who has any kind of a secret regarding parentage in the family background. I'd say this is an excellent reason for parents to be completely honest with their children about these things. The vast majority of adoptive parents tell their kids they are adopted and they often know the birth parents while they are growing up. But there are a large number of children out there who were conceived as a result of their mother using a sperm donor or an egg donor or both who do NOT know this is the case. A lot of parents who use donors never tell the kids. So what happens in 15 or 20 years if those kids send in their DNA test kits to 23andme? Probably pretty much what happened with that very distant DNA relative of mine who discovered her father isn't her biological father and is now angry at both parents.


Oct-10-13 8:25 AM

It should read "In some cases" above. My iPad garbles things.


Oct-10-13 8:23 AM

I think it can give you new information to give your doctor income cases, though it's not the only thing you should rely on healthwise. It didn't tell me anything I didn't know already, just based on what diseases My grandparents and great grandparents had. But not everyone knows as much as I do about my grandparents and great grandparents. I could see it being really useful for adoptees who don't have a family medical history. You can choose not to make your profile public or have it search for DNA relatives If you want more privacy. It also gives you a choice whether to find out if you have the early onset Alzheimer's gene or Parkinson's gene. I have neither.


Oct-09-13 4:58 PM

Luckily, I am not a carrier for any horrible diseases, nor do I have gene mutations that could be used to deny me life insurance. Nor have I committed any crimes for which there is DNA evidence on file in a cold case unit. There are also no deep, dark paternity secrets in my immediate family. I knew all of that before I considered having the testing done. If anyone desperately wants a DNA sample from me, it would have been easy enough to obtain legally, unfortunately, given the current state of our legal system. All they'd have to do is put me under surveillance and take a cup I threw in the trash. I don't really see why they'd bother. Plus, I wanted to find out who I was related to in Finland, so I thought the positives outweighed the negatives in my case.


Post a Comment

You must first login before you can comment.

*Your email address:
Remember my email address.


I am looking for:
News, Blogs & Events Web